Friday, August 5, 2016

News & Views
7/30/16-8/5/16

Summer Games are afoot. Rio’s opening ceremony airs tonight and Lucioball is talking folks by storm in Overwatch. While you wait, why not sit down to read a few pieces of great gaming writing?

News & Views collects the week’s best writing about video games and puts it into one convenient place. Check out the links below for stories about the relationship between goats and DOOM, the insane fan culture that’s arisen around No Man’s Sky, and the less than stellar race politics of the new Deus Ex game.

And of course please check out the brand new episode of The Impact Factor podcast that was posted today! You can subscribe to the podcast on iTunes, or if you prefer other methods, check out our SoundCloud. We’re on YouTube too!

Spotlight
Patrick Stafford, Polygon

Worth Reading
Austin Walker, VICE

Patrick Klepek, Kotaku

Maddi Chilton, Kill Screen

Reid McCarter, Kill Screen

Mantin Lu, Gamasutra

With Comments
Matt Sayer, Unwinnable
As a long time Souls fan I’ve long wondered if there was a way to make the games more accessible without compromising their unrivaled design. The answer to my own question was typically a resounding no. Matt Sayer also investigates this question. He provides some possible avenues to consider: like directing the player to focus their attack on a specific part of the boss via glowing limbs, or warnings for players about to fall to their deaths. I like what he’s trying here, but disagree that these would work. More thought is needed.

Emeric Thoa, Gamasutra
I quite enjoyed Furi. I really appreciated how dedicated that game was to its core principles, for better and worse. Emeric Thoa, one of the game’s designers, writes about their philosophy for the game. Of the most interesting aspects is The Game Bakers’ goal to make a ‘triple I’ game. It centers around the idea that you cannot compete with AAAs in terms of scope, so you must focus on one feature and make it exceptional. This will help your game stand out among indies. Thoa also writes about how, in doing so, you cannot worry about alienating a large audience—you can’t please everyone. 
The Impact Factor Ep. 66: Admitting You Play Games
Podcast
Welcome to the 66th episode of The Impact Factor! The Impact Factor is what happens when two scientists, and two best friends, get together to talk about video games. Hosts Alex Samocha [biomedical scientist] and Charles Fliss [social scientist] sit down every week to discuss the week in gaming! Listen in for the news, views, and games that made the biggest impact!

Please send your suggestions and feedback to: impactfactorpodcast@gmail.com

In this episode Alex and Fliss talk about PS Vita hacks, Hearthstone, Overwatch, Pokemon Sun & Moon, Inside, Darkest Dungeon, 1 billion iPhones sold, PlayStation profits, I Am Setsuna, and how we talk about video games to people who don’t play.


YouTube page

For articles and reviews from Alex, check out: www.theimpactfactor.blogspot.com
For a blog about Japan, pop culture & more from Fliss, check out:

Follow Alex @alexsamocha on Twitter. twitch.tv/megalodonphd
Follow Fliss 
@thecfliss on Twitter. twitch.tv/flissofthenorthstar

Intro song:
You Kill My Brother by Go! Go! Go! Micro Invasion, East Jakarta Chiptunes Compilations. Freemusic Archive. (Attribution Noncommercial Share-Alike License)
Transitions:
News & Views and Perspectives transitions from victorcenusa, Freesound.org (Creative Commons 0 License)
Experimental Methods transition from Sentuniman, Freesound.org (Attribution Noncommercial License)

Tuesday, August 2, 2016

One Hell Of A Good Time
Review
DOOM, id Software (PS4)

Abstract: DOOM (2016) is a perfect blend of old and new, bringing players back to the way we used to play first-person shooters while smartly adapting and incorporating 20+ years of design insight along the way. DOOM is fast and frantic, bloody and brutal, and has some of the tightest designed gameplay I’ve seen all year. Glory Kills change the way you play, reinforcing DOOM’s themes and solving a long-entrenched issue in first-person shooters. Great gunplay and rewarding exploration form a strong gameplay loop that keeps players engaged through DOOM’s admittedly weak story. A few poorly designed encounters and underwhelming bosses detract from the experience, but DOOM is very much worth playing. It’s one hell of a good time.

For video game enthusiasts my age, the original Doom was groundbreaking. It redefined how I understood video games. Whether it was staying up late to play or booting it up when the computer lab teacher stepped out of the room, Doom was on the forefront of my gaming brain from a very early age. Simply put, there had never been anything quite like it. Doom was dark, gritty and violent during a time most of my gaming time was spent in “edutainment” titles. Doom was fast, almost incomprehensibly so, at a time games were often sluggish. Doom felt deeply complex, with secrets cleverly hidden around every corner, weapons to find, and strategies you had to enact on the fly to defeat some of the game’s tougher demons. Doom was the future.

Over time the rest of the world caught up. Doom’s formula was tweaked and adapted in a variety of ways in a variety of games. Doom followed up with a spectacular sequel, but then it all sort of dropped off. Released in 2004, Doom 3 was an underwhelming, slow, resource-oriented survival horror game. And then there was nothing. That is, until DOOM (2016) released. Could a very different id Software return to the long dormant IP to do something exciting? Could it recapture the magic of the first two titles? For the most part, that answer is a resounding yes.

DOOM starts as the player is pulled from a coffin into a blood-soaked room. The Doom Marine makes short work of the handful of demons guarding his place of slumber. You know in an instant that this is not, and will not be, a survival horror game. You’re the Doom Marine, you’re a force to be reckoned with, and demons should be scared. A quick stroll over to some conveniently placed armor (called a Praetor Suit), and you’re off to learn who you are, where you are, and what needs to be done. You quickly discover that you’re on Mars in a facility that was designed to mine “argent energy” directly from Hell. Things went awry, as they always do, allowing Hell’s demons to kill, mutilate, or possess the majority of the facility’s personnel. The story beats throughout your journey are well-tread ground for first- and third-person shooter games. You need to get from A to B but the power is off, so go find and flip a switch. You need to gain access to some remote terminal. And so on. The game’s story takes you through the majority of the facility and into Hell itself. The narrative framework is weak—just enough to keep the player moving in the right direction and mostly aware of what he or she is doing. For most games, a story this poor would be a major negative. Not for DOOM though. DOOM is about killin’ demons.

I'm here to kill demons and chew bubble gu...
Wait wrong game.
Gameplay is king. As you might expect, the majority of your playtime is spent blowing away demons. The gunplay is so satisfyingly designed. DOOM eschews the conventions that so many modern first-person shooters adhere to. Your health doesn’t regenerate. The majority of your weapons cannot be aimed down the sights. Ammo, armor, health packs, and even weapons can be found strewn around the map. And DOOM is fast. Intensely fast. The Doom Marine zips around at breakneck speeds and demons move just as fast. Mobility is emphasized in all regards. In many ways, so much of what I described is a throwback to the first-person shooters of times past. DOOM (2016) plays more similarly to Doom than any shooter I’ve played in years. It’s refreshing. That’s not to say DOOM hasn’t learned from the 20+ years of development insight since Doom II released. It adapts systems that work within its old-is-new context. Your Praetor suit, for example, can be powered up by collecting points from downed marines around the map. Argent energy points can be used to level up your health, armor, and ammo totals. You can also find, equip, and level up runes that boost particular stats. DOOM smartly adapts the player progression systems of modern titles into its fast, frantic old-school gameplay experience.

Old-school never felt so new. And so fun.
Your speed is complemented by DOOM’s array of fantastic weapons. Killing demons is an absolute joy. No two guns are alike, though each is viable and allows for different approaches to butchering the agents of evil. Weapons look and sound powerful. My go-to setup was the infamous Super Shotgun and the slow but devastating Gauss Cannon. Like your suit, guns too can be leveled up and customized, each having two separate modifications that add alternate firing methods. DOOM rewards you for trying new things and gives players the tools to play however they like. As you explore you’ll find a handful of demons along your way—small packs that can be quickly dispatched. Other encounters are more entrenched, in which you come upon a set location with waves of demons that will spawn in to attack. This dynamic creates a compelling gameplay loop of explore, kill, entrench, kill, repeat. And the loop is always, always fun. From a raw gameplay perspective, DOOM easily ranks among the top of games released this year.

Adding to that is the ingenious “Glory Kill” system. So many first-person shooters lack momentum. They often devolve into boring shooting galleries. And why is that the case (bad encounter design aside)? Health. In a game like Call of Duty, a lot of your time is spent hiding behind cover as your health slowly regenerates. You take damage because you want to be aggressive, but you can’t sustain your aggression because you’ll die. DOOM fixes this problem in the most Doom-like way possible. As stated earlier, your health does not regenerate. But DOOM doesn’t want you running away from battle to look for health packs. No way. Enter the Glory Kill. When a demon takes enough damage they’ll start to flash blue/orange. If you melee (R3 on PS4) a flashing demon you get a Glory Kill. Glory Kills are brutally animated finishing attacks, like crushing the demon’s head between your hands or ripping off the demon’s arm and smacking him with it. Any demon finished off by a Glory Kill will drop health and ammo. That means that, when your health is low, DOOM encourages you to not only stay in the fight but to get right up in a demon’s face. It maintains the fast and frantic pace of DOOM’s gunplay, adds to the already effective power fantasy, and solves one of my biggest issues with first-person shooter campaigns. Win win win.

Glory Kills are a smart, gory solution to one of first-person shooter's
biggest problems.
Playing through DOOM’s campaign is a linear experience, but one that is ripe with exploration. The game is separated into 13 distinct levels. Each level is a sprawling map, open to the player to be explored in any way they see fit. You can run directly to the marked objectives or run the opposite way in search of hidden secrets. Speaking of secrets, there are plenty. A thorough scouring of the map will have the player come across extra Praetor points, new weapon mods, argent energy reserves, miniature “Doom Guy” dolls, and even classic Doom maps. Levels are absolutely packed with secrets and collectibles, and I felt compelled to discover each and every one. Finding them isn’t always so easy, though, as one quick glance at the in-game map will show you. DOOM’s levels are mazelike, weaving and intersecting in ways that demand a good sense of geography to fully grasp.

Hey little buddy. DOOM pushes you to collect 'em all.
PS: Try dying in lava. You won't regret it.
While I mostly enjoyed the large map size, it did pose a few gameplay problems. Getting around these large maps, especially when on the hunt for collectibles, can take quite a while and involve a lot of backtracking. This wouldn’t be a huge issue if not for how valuable some of these collectibles are. Without thoroughly searching the map, the player cannot fully upgrade their weapons, suit, or character by the game’s end. On the “Hurt Me Plenty” difficulty I never had too tough a time killing my foes, but I also maxed out my character whenever I could. For less experienced players or on harder difficulties, the reliance on finding secret items to fully power up your Doom Marine could pose a problem. Further, poor map design in a few of the entrenched encounters I described earlier was a bummer. Verticality is a key feature for these encounters, but I found several instances in which there was simply too much. Several common demons are fond of running away from the player, and when a map is too large and too vertical, it can be hard to chase them down. The result is a frustrating game of cat and mouse that drags these encounters down. And speaking of underwhelming encounters, DOOM features a small handful of bosses and none of which are particularly exciting or memorable. The final boss, for example, was laughably easy and felt like a strange note to end on for an otherwise extraordinary experience.

I cannot properly review DOOM without mentioning how absolutely stunning its visuals are. DOOM is a gorgeous game. Id Software blew me away with how crisp and detailed everything is, from guns to demons to environments. Despite lacking in geographic diversity, I loved looking at the different Mars facilities, the planet, and the handful of Hell zones I was taken to. The visuals are complemented by a gritty metal soundtrack that perfectly kicks in during heated battles. When I find myself stopping to admire the scenery and take screenshots, I know a game nails its presentation.

She's a looker alright.
At the year’s start, I had little to no interest in playing DOOM. How could it encapsulate that perfect “Doom” experience in modern setting? I am so happy to be proven wrong. Id Software made a fantastic hybrid of old and new that touts some of 2016’s best raw gameplay. My experience hasn’t really stuck with me, and I’m not too sure why, but it does not change the fact that I had one hell of a good time playing through DOOM.

DOOM
4/5

Monday, August 1, 2016

TIF Plays: Week of 7/25-7/29
Gameplay

Welcome to the The Impact Factor's last week of gameplay! Check out below to links of all my gameplay. Be sure to catch me live on Twitch (MegalodonPhD). I stream every Tuesday and Thursday at 5:30pm PT. Plus some special Friday streams, too! You can do me a favor by subscribing to The Impact Factor's YouTube channel, but hey, don't let me tell you what to do! 

To keep up to date with everything The Impact Factor, and me, follow me on Twitter: @alexsamocha

See you all next week!


Friday, July 29, 2016

News & Views
7/23/16-7/29/16

News & Views collects the week’s best video game writing into one convenient place. Check out the links below for stories about how Pokémon GO does a terrible job teaching players how to play, why annoyance is a key part of great game design, and how VR is more about control than immersion.

And of course please check out the brand new episode of The Impact Factor podcast that was posted today! You can subscribe to the podcast on iTunes, or if you prefer other methods, check out our SoundCloud. We’re on YouTube too!

Spotlight
Tom Francis, Eurogamer

Worth Reading
Josh Bycer, Gamasutra

Nico Deyo, Paste

Rich Stanton, The Guardian

Bhernardo Viana, Mammon Machine

Chris Kohler, Wired

Sebastian Long, Gamasutra

Michael Martin, Yahoo eSports

Rowan Kaier, Polygon

Cameron Kunzelman, VICE
The Impact Factor Ep. 65: ResidentSleeper aka Wormhole Boys
Podcast
Welcome to the 65th episode of The Impact Factor! The Impact Factor is what happens when two scientists, and two best friends, get together to talk about video games. Hosts Alex Samocha [biomedical scientist] and Charles Fliss [social scientist] sit down every week to discuss the week in gaming! Listen in for the news, views, and games that made the biggest impact!

Please send your suggestions and feedback to: impactfactorpodcast@gmail.com

In this episode Alex and Fliss talk about SDCC, eSports, Overwatch, Injustice 2, Nintendo NX, Sonic the Hedgehog, Telltale’s Batman, The International 2016, video game sequels, DOOM, Street Fighter V story mode, Blair Witch and much more!

"How I learned to stop worrying and love video game sequels" Josh Bycer, Gamasutra


YouTube page

For articles and reviews from Alex, check out: www.theimpactfactor.blogspot.com
For a blog about Japan, pop culture & more from Fliss, check out:

Follow Alex @alexsamocha on Twitter. twitch.tv/megalodonphd
Follow Fliss 
@thecfliss on Twitter. twitch.tv/flissofthenorthstar

Intro song:
You Kill My Brother by Go! Go! Go! Micro Invasion, East Jakarta Chiptunes Compilations. Freemusic Archive. (Attribution Noncommercial Share-Alike License)
Transitions:
News & Views and Perspectives transitions from victorcenusa, Freesound.org (Creative Commons 0 License)
Experimental Methods transition from Sentuniman, Freesound.org (Attribution Noncommercial License)

Tuesday, July 26, 2016

A Musical Of Punches: Disjointed Narrative and Street Fighter V
Perspectives

Abstract: Street Fighter V’s long awaited story mode is terrible. The writing is poor and the plot is something you’ve already seen a thousand times. The narrative and gameplay poorly align, transforming the story mode into a bizarre musical where punches and shoryukens are the songs. Like many other games, Street Fighter V makes the mistake of relying too strongly on film as the model on how to shape its story. When video games lean into what makes them unique from movies, like their interactivity and perspective, their narratives can succeed.

Let’s not beat around the bush here, Street Fighter V’s story mode is bad. Almost unplayably so. It is a huge bummer. As a kid that grew up glued to the shiny Street Fighter II arcade cabinet, I spent hours creating the world of Street Fighter in my mind. From character dialogue to stages to moves, I used everything I could to create the universe. Given my past experience with Capcom fighting games my expectations for Street Fighter V’s story mode were quite low. It promised to be a step above the comic book freeze frame storytelling of Capcom’s games past games, with 3D models and dialogue and a compelling narrative. I suppose it delivers two of the three.

As of writing this, I’m a little past the story mode’s halfway point. What I’ve experienced so far is 90 minutes of stilted dialogue and haphazardly assembled vignettes that roughly come together to form a narrative. Street Fighter V’s story mode represents so much of what has been wrong with narrative in video games. The writing is god awful. The plot is something a middle-schooler could have whipped up on a lazy afternoon. The action is disjointed—characters hop around with little to no sense of geography or time, motivations shift dynamically and without purpose, and every scene is just an excuse to hobble together an eclectic group of characters to, you guessed it, fight each other. Street Fighter V’s final offense is one that’s been committed over and over again in video games: the gameplay and story are totally disconnected.

Guys, please. Street Fighter V's story isn't worth the fist bump.
Street Fighter V’s story mode is broken up into two discrete parts: non-interactive cutscenes and fights. Never do the two really meet. The narrative heft is put forward in the cutscenes. The Shadaloo bad guys explain why they want to EMP the world, the good guys talk with one another to plan how to stop the evil organization, etc. The fighting, however, exists almost totally outside of the story. In fact, most fights in the story feel forcefully injected between the plot that’s taking place. Characters will get mad at one another at the drop of a dime, or out of the blue will demand a test of a fighter’s skill. Anything to get two people to clash. Playing through the story mode is a strange experience. The shift between cutscene movie and fights is jarring. Many characters come across as trigger-happy psychopaths looking for any excuse to hadouken one another. Street Fighter V’s story mode never lets characters earn their right to fight one another, nor does it skillfully blend fighting in with the larger narrative.

I'm sure you can guess the outcome of the scene by now.
In many ways, playing Street Fighter V’s story mode is like watching a musical. The characters go about their business until BAM, they suddenly need to fight. Like a musical in which people suddenly need to sing. This isn’t the first time this particular dissonance between gameplay and story has been compared to theater. Scott Pilgrim vs. the World director Edgar Wright described how he approached blending the titular character’s fights into the film saying, “We thought it should play out like a musical in a way in terms of the fights are not dissimilar to the songs.” Scott Pilgrim leaned heavily on video games as an influence. This approach worked for Scott Pilgrim, perhaps given the strength of the writing and directing of the film. It doesn’t change the fact that the fights are jarring, dislodging the viewer (if only momentarily) from the experience. That jolt has a more profound impact when playing a video game like Street Fighter V. The player agency in the action combined with the general interactivity of video games make it so that, when gameplay is inelegantly inserted into game’s narrative, you’re thrown pretty far off from the experience.

Scott Pilgrim is a good musical of punches. Street Fighter V is not.
Street Fighter V also suffers from a problem very recently highlighted by the great Brad Bird. Bird shared his concerns about using video games as inspiration for filmmaking and storytelling in a recent interview. The director of The Iron Giant and The Incredibles cited video games’ point of view problem. He said, “I feel like video games are a bad influence for storytelling because they are not directed points of view. They are about floating around universes…a lot of times it’s just motion.” Story mode in Street Fighter V is all about universe and not about a singular, or cohesive, point of view. Perspective shifts happen every couple minutes. Huge fluctuations in characters and tones and locations happen so frequently it is easy to get lost in the fold. By giving every character equal representation in the plot, no one matters. The end result is schizophrenic and astonishingly boring. There’s nothing compelling you to get attached or to move forward.

As inflammatory as Bird’s statement can come off, he does hit on a truth that video game narrative creators need to realize. Simply adapting a film approach and applying it to video games rarely works. It is immediately obvious that Street Fighter V wants the story mode to feel like a movie. Fortunately we already know how well a Street Fighter movie works, and it’s not very pretty. Games have long thought going the Hollywood route is the way to bring great narratives into video games. Rarely is that the case. Only the true masters of the craft can get away with this approach, like Naughty Dog with The Last of Us and Uncharted 4. Nearly every other film-inspired story mode in video games comes across, at best, like a good “B” movie. It’s a point of view problem, it’s a length problem, and it’s an interactivity problem.

Unless you're Naughty Dog, your studio might want to think twice about
making your story "cinematic."
While Street Fighter V fundamentally misunderstands what makes a video game story great (hint: it’s not about making a musical of punches), other games shape narrative construction to fit the unique vehicle that is video games. In response to Brad Bird’s statement about video game narrative, creative lead at Naughty Dog Neil Druckman tweeted, “Someone needs to play Brothers [A Tale of Two Sons] or Ico or Papers Please or Portal or Inside or The Secret of Monkey Island or…” Druckman is right and Bird is wrong. There are fantastic narrative in games. Druckman’s list has something in common, though—none of these games structure their story like a movie. Video game narratives work when they lean into the interactivity inherent in games, and from the unique perspectives games can offer the player. Certain narrative devices like environmental storytelling work so well in games, even outshining their film peers. Games like Gone Home and Portal and Ico and Firewatch have fantastic narratives that would never work the same way on film. Video game narratives have the potential for greatness when they are designed from the ground up to be a video game narrative, not a movie facsimile.

The best video game stories adapt narrative structures to fit
the interactive medium they exist within.
For my love of Street Fighter and its characters I’ll fight my way to the end of Street Fighter V’s story mode. I owe it to my arcade heritage and my fondness for the fighting game community. I just wish Street Fighter V was more Shadow of the Colossus and less “action-movie the fighting game musical."